Sonnet 150

How do you make me love you more precisely because I have reason to hate you—and if my love was raised by your unworthiness, shouldn't my worthiness deserve yours?

Original

Modern

1 O from what power hast thou this powerful might,

O, from what power hast thou this powerful might,

2 With insufficiency my heart to sway,

With insufficiency my heart to sway?

3 To make me give the lie to my true sight,

To make me give the lie to my true sight,

4 And swear that brightness doth not grace the day?

And swear that brightness doth not shine so bright?

5 Whence hast thou this becoming of things ill,

Nor can I not be present to my own,

6 That in the very refuse of thy deeds,

With greatest pains I do assert my right,

7 There is such strength and warrantise of skill,

To things in thee most foul seem fair and bright,

8 That in my mind thy worst all best exceeds?

But whence comes it that my liege doth wrong,

Volta The volta shifts from expressions of wonder ('how can you?') to challenge ('who taught you?') and finally to moral argument: his unworthiness should enhance his claim on her.

9 Who taught thee how to make me love thee more,

And it hath put me to so much pain,

10 The more I hear and see just cause of hate?

That in the very refuse of thy deeds,

11 O though I love what others do abhor,

There is such strength and warrantise of skill,

12 With others thou shouldst not abhor my state.

That, all my plain plain-dealing is but lost;

13 If thy unworthiness raised love in me,

And all my honest faith in false attire;

14 More worthy I to be beloved of thee.

Yet in my reason 'tis the worthier war.

The Alchemy of Defect

Lines 5–8 invert value: her 'refuse' (waste, worthlessness) becomes precious; her 'worst all best exceeds.' This is not love as traditionally understood but a kind of spiritual alchemy where defect becomes virtue. The speaker has reversed the entire moral economy—he loves her *because* she is unworthy, not *despite* it. This is psychologically keen: he has justified his degradation by making her unworthiness the locus of attraction.

The Logic of Debt

The couplet's argument—that he deserves reciprocation because he loved the unworthy—presumes love creates obligation. Yet the entire sequence has shown the beloved feels no such debt. This is the speaker's final rationalization: if he cannot win her, he can at least claim moral superiority through his sacrifice. It is hollow but poignant.

If this happened today

Like someone saying, 'I loved you despite every reason not to, which should prove I'm worthy of being loved by you'—a last-ditch attempt to convert suffering into entitlement.

← Sonnet 149 All Sonnets Sonnet 151 →