← 1.2
Act 1, Scene 3 — London. Before the Tower.
on stage:
Next: 1.4 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Gloucester attempts to inspect the Tower of London, but Winchester has ordered his men barred; the two factions brawl in the street until the Mayor of London intervenes.
Enter the Duke of Gloucester with his Servingmen in blue coats.
GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Official inspection tinged with suspicion; Gloucester asserts his authority

I am come to survey the Tower this day.

Since Henry’s death, I fear, there is conveyance.

Where be these warders that they wait not here?

Open the gates; ’tis Gloucester that calls.

I have come to inspect the Tower this day. Since Henry's death, I fear there has been improper conduct here. Where are the warders? Why are they not at their posts? Open the gates—it is Gloucester who calls.

I'm here to check on the Tower. Something's wrong since Henry died. Where are the guards? They should be waiting for me. Open these gates. I'm the Protector.

Tower check where are the guards they should be here I'm Gloucester open up

[_Within_.] Who’s there that knocks so imperiously?
FIRST SERVINGMAN Formal identification carrying deference

It is the noble Duke of Gloucester.

It is the noble Duke of Gloucester.

It's the Duke of Gloucester.

it's him Gloucester the Duke

[_Within_.] Whoe’er he be, you may not be let in.
FIRST SERVINGMAN Outraged challenge; a servant defends his lord's authority

Villains, answer you so the Lord Protector?

You villains, is this how you answer the Lord Protector?

You bastards—is this how you treat the Protector?

you villains this is the Protector answer him

[_Within_.] The Lord protect him, so we answer him.
FIRST WARDER Flat obedience invoking higher orders

We do no otherwise than we are will’d.

We do only what we are commanded to do.

We're following our orders.

we follow orders not ours to change

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Authority tested and burning to assert dominance

Who willed you? Or whose will stands but mine?

There’s none Protector of the realm but I.

Break up the gates, I’ll be your warrantize.

Shall I be flouted thus by dunghill grooms?

Who gave you orders? Whose will stands above mine? There is no Protector of this realm but me. Break down these gates—I will take responsibility. Should I be insulted by grooms from the dungheap?

Who ordered you to defy me? Is there anyone with more power than I have? I'm the Protector of England. Tear down those gates. I'll answer for it. Am I supposed to be humiliated by servants?

who ordered this I'm Protector I am break the gates I'll take it I won't be insulted

[_Gloucester’s men rush at the Tower gates, and Woodville, the
Lieutenant, speaks within._]
First appearance
WOODVILLE

Woodville is a minor character who represents the Tower's institutional loyalty — he follows whoever gave him his last orders, in this case Winchester. He's the face of bureaucratic compliance in a system where everyone's shouting different commands.

WOODVILLE Alarm at military threat; Woodville demands explanation

What noise is this? What traitors have we here?

What is this noise? What rebels are inside?

What's happening? Who's attacking?

noise what's the attack who's inside

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Recognition mixed with assertion

Lieutenant, is it you whose voice I hear?

Open the gates; here’s Gloucester that would enter.

Woodville, is it you whose voice I hear? Open the gates. Gloucester is here and wishes to enter.

Is that you, Woodville? Let me in. It's Gloucester.

Woodville open it's me Gloucester

WOODVILLE ≋ verse Caught between loyalty and obedience; Woodville relays the cardinal's order

Have patience, noble Duke; I may not open;

The Cardinal of Winchester forbids.

From him I have express commandment

That thou nor none of thine shall be let in.

Patience, noble Duke—I cannot open. The Cardinal of Winchester has forbidden it. I have his direct command that neither you nor your men shall enter.

Wait, my lord. I can't open the gates. The Cardinal of Winchester ordered me not to. Nobody gets in—that's his command.

can't winchester forbids his order no one in not even you

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Outrage erupting into threat; Gloucester turns on Woodville and Winchester

Faint-hearted Woodville, prizest him ’fore me?

Arrogant Winchester, that haughty prelate

Whom Henry, our late sovereign, ne’er could brook?

Thou art no friend to God or to the King.

Open the gates, or I’ll shut thee out shortly.

Timid Woodville, you prefer Winchester to me? Arrogant Winchester, that haughty bishop whom King Henry never could tolerate? You are no friend to God or the King. Open the gates or I will shut you out shortly.

You're choosing Winchester over me? That's what this is. Winchester—that proud bishop Henry could never stand—you're picking him. You're betraying both God and the King. Open these gates or I'll make sure you never give orders again.

you pick Winchester over me over the King over God open or I finish this

SERVINGMEN ≋ verse Aggressive chorus; Gloucester's men back him with threat

Open the gates unto the Lord Protector,

Or we’ll burst them open, if that you come not quickly.

Open the gates to the Lord Protector, or we will break them down if you do not hurry.

Let the Protector in or we're breaking these gates ourselves.

open protector now or we break them

Enter to the Protector at the Tower gates Winchester and his men in
tawny coats.
WINCHESTER Aggressive challenge masquerading as greeting; Winchester tests Gloucester

How now, ambitious Humphrey! What means this?

How now, ambitious Humphrey? What does this mean?

What's this, Humphrey? Some kind of power play?

what's happening Humphrey what do you want

GLOUCESTER Bristling with contempt; Gloucester strikes first

Peel’d priest, dost thou command me to be shut out?

Stripped priest, do you command me to be locked out?

You—you who gave up the cloth—you're ordering me around?

you priest you lock me out I don't think so

WINCHESTER ≋ verse Bristling defensiveness; Winchester claims innocence

I do, thou most usurping proditor,

And not Protector, of the King or realm.

No orders from me, Humphrey. I only pray you keep the peace.

I didn't order anything. I'm asking for peace.

no order I want peace that's all

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Sarcastic accusation; Gloucester turns Winchester's words against him

Stand back, thou manifest conspirator,

Thou that contrived’st to murder our dead lord;

Thou that giv’st whores indulgences to sin:

I’ll canvass thee in thy broad cardinal’s hat,

If thou proceed in this thy insolence.

Peace? You speak of peace while armed men stand at your back. That is not peace—that is preparation for war.

Peace? You came with soldiers at your back. That's not peace—that's war getting ready to happen.

peace with armed men behind you that's not peace that's war

WINCHESTER ≋ verse Threats escalating; both men posture for dominance

Nay, stand thou back; I will not budge a foot.

This be Damascus, be thou cursed Cain,

To slay thy brother Abel, if thou wilt.

Nay, if words will not serve, we shall try swords. I will not have a bishop teach me what duty means.

If you want to settle this with steel, I'm ready. A bishop doesn't get to lecture me.

swords then if words fail a bishop won't rule me

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Matching aggression; Winchester refuses to back down

I will not slay thee, but I’ll drive thee back.

Thy scarlet robes, as a child’s bearing-cloth,

I’ll use to carry thee out of this place.

Gloucester, I will not yield to your rough manners. Stand off with your weapons or face the consequence.

Back off, Gloucester. Keep your hands to yourself or you'll regret it.

back off Humphrey or suffer

WINCHESTER Authority invoked to stop violence; Exeter plays peacemaker

Do what thou dar’st, I beard thee to thy face.

My lords, for shame! Would you spill blood here, at the King's own residence? Peace, for God's sake, peace!

My lords, stop! This is the King's house—are you going to fight here? Please, stop this.

stop the King's house no bloodshed please

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Resentment masked by compliance; both men obey Exeter

What, am I dared and bearded to my face?

Draw, men, for all this privileged place.

Blue coats to tawny coats. Priest, beware your beard;

I mean to tug it and to cuff you soundly.

Under my feet I’ll stamp thy cardinal’s hat;

In spite of Pope or dignities of church,

Here by the cheeks I’ll drag thee up and down.

Gloucester, you have your way. Take control of the Tower and the munitions. Winchester, you shall answer at court for this overreach.

Gloucester, go in. Winchester, you're explaining this to the King.

go in Gloucester Winchester you'll answer

"Blue coats to tawny coats" The factions are color-coded: Gloucester's men wore blue livery, Winchester's wore tawny (brownish-orange). The audience could track allegiances at a glance — the whole scene is choreographed around these rival colors.
WINCHESTER Bitter parting shots; defeat swallowed but not accepted

Gloucester, thou wilt answer this before the Pope.

This is not finished. A day will come when Gloucester falls, and I will be there to watch.

This isn't over. One day you'll lose power and I'll be waiting.

not over Gloucester one day you'll fall I'll watch

GLOUCESTER Equally bitter response; Gloucester sets the terms

Winchester goose, I cry, “a rope, a rope!”

Now beat them hence; why do you let them stay?

Thee I’ll chase hence, thou wolf in sheep’s array.

Out, tawny coats! Out, scarlet hypocrite!

Here Gloucester’s men beat out the Cardinal’s men, and enter in the

hurly-burly the Mayor of London and his Officers.

Let that day come when it will. Until then, know that I rule in the King's name and no cardinal will contradict me.

Whenever that is. Until then, I run this kingdom and you'll obey.

let it come I rule now you obey

First appearance
MAYOR

The Mayor is London's beleaguered civil authority — decent, ineffectual, perpetually exasperated by the nobles' contempt for law. His lines are often the scene's comic punctuation: watch for the gap between his formal proclamations and the complete chaos that ignores them.

MAYOR ≋ verse Appalled official protest; the Mayor tries to restore order

Fie, lords, that you, being supreme magistrates,

Thus contumeliously should break the peace!

Shame on you, lords! You are the highest magistrates, and yet you violently break the King's peace!

You're the leaders! How can you fight like this? You're supposed to keep the peace!

shame you're supposed to lead keep peace stop this fight

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Dismissive refusal; Gloucester lectures the Mayor

Peace, Mayor! Thou know’st little of my wrongs.

Here’s Beaufort, that regards nor God nor king,

Hath here distrain’d the Tower to his use.

Peace, Mayor! You know nothing of my grievances. This Beaufort—Winchester—cares neither for God nor the King. He has seized the Tower for his own purposes.

You don't get it. Winchester doesn't care about God or the King. He's taken over the Tower.

you don't understand Winchester no God no King stole the Tower

WINCHESTER ≋ verse Counter-accusation; Winchester attacks Gloucester's record

Here’s Gloucester, a foe to citizens,

One that still motions war and never peace,

O’ercharging your free purses with large fines;

That seeks to overthrow religion,

Because he is Protector of the realm,

And would have armour here out of the Tower,

To crown himself king and suppress the Prince.

Here stands Gloucester, an enemy to the citizens! He constantly stirs up war and prevents peace. He drains your coffers with heavy fines.

Gloucester—he's against you all. He starts wars, kills peace, and bleeds you dry with fines.

Gloucester enemy to you makes wars bleeds you dry fines fines

GLOUCESTER Final escalation; Gloucester abandons words for action

I will not answer thee with words, but blows.

I will not answer you with words anymore. Now we answer with swords.

Enough talking. Now we fight.

no more words fight now swords

[_Here they skirmish again._]
MAYOR ≋ verse Civic duty overwhelmed; the Mayor invokes legal authority

Nought rests for me in this tumultuous strife

But to make open proclamation.

Come, officer, as loud as e’er thou canst, cry.

There is nothing left for me to do in this chaos but to issue a formal proclamation. Officer, announce as loudly as you can.

I'm going to use the only power I have left. Officer, read the order.

proclamation official order read it loud stop this

OFFICER Bureaucratic command straining against disorder; the Officer reads

All manner of men assembled here in arms this day against God’s peace

and the King’s, we charge and command you, in his Highness’ name, to

repair to your several dwelling-places; and not to wear, handle, or use

any sword, weapon, or dagger, henceforward, upon pain of death.

By order of the King: all manner of armed men assembled here this day against God's peace and the King's are commanded to go to your homes and surrender all weapons.

The King says: everyone here is breaking the law. Go home. Give up your weapons.

King's order law go home give up weapons all of you

GLOUCESTER ≋ verse Calculated compliance; Gloucester bows while asserting future power

Cardinal, I’ll be no breaker of the law;

But we shall meet and break our minds at large.

Cardinal, I will not break the law. But we will meet again and settle this fully.

I'll follow the law. But Winchester—we're not done.

I'll obey for now but we'll meet again this isn't over

WINCHESTER ≋ verse Murderous vow; Winchester promises Gloucester death

Gloucester, we will meet, to thy cost, be sure;

Thy heart-blood I will have for this day’s work.

Gloucester, we will meet again, and it will cost you dearly. I swear I will have your blood before this day is done.

You'll pay for this, Gloucester. I'm going to kill you.

you'll pay Gloucester your blood I swear it

MAYOR ≋ verse Desperate authority; the Mayor threatens last resort

I’ll call for clubs, if you will not away.

This Cardinal’s more haughty than the devil.

I will call my citizens with clubs if you do not leave at once. This Cardinal is more arrogant than the devil himself.

Get out now or I'll call people with sticks to beat you out. Winchester's worse than the devil.

leave now or I call the mob Winchester worse than evil

GLOUCESTER Dignified concession; Gloucester accepts the Mayor's authority

Mayor, farewell. Thou dost but what thou mayst.

Mayor, farewell. You do what you can and must. This is a losing battle for both of us.

You're just doing your job, Mayor. I understand.

goodbye you did right your job thanks

WINCHESTER ≋ verse Parting threat; Winchester's menace follows Gloucester out

Abominable Gloucester, guard thy head,

For I intend to have it ere long.

Abominable Gloucester, beware your head! I fully intend to have it before long.

Watch your back, Gloucester. I'll get you.

watch out Gloucester I'm coming for you

[_Exeunt, severally, Gloucester and Winchester with their Servingmen._]
MAYOR ≋ verse Weary resignation masking outrage; the Mayor witnesses decline

See the coast clear’d, and then we will depart.

Good God, these nobles should such stomachs bear!

I myself fight not once in forty year.

Clear the streets. Then we will leave. Good God, that nobles should have such fierce temperaments! I myself have not fought in forty years.

Get everyone out. Look—these nobles fight constantly. I haven't fought in forty years.

clear the streets get them out these nobles fighting always fighting I'm old not used to this

[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

The domestic English storyline erupts into physical comedy. Two of the most powerful men in England have turned into street fighters, their retinues pelting each other with weapons (and later pebbles) outside the Tower. The Mayor's helpless exasperation is the scene's comic register — but the violence has a sour undercurrent: this is what happens when the king is a child and his guardians hate each other.

If this happened today…

Two vice-presidents at a company whose CEO just died are both trying to access the main server room. One has brought his whole team in matching blue jackets; the other has stationed his people at the door in brown. The IT manager inside says he can't let anyone in — HR has locked it down on orders from the other VP. The two factions start shoving in the lobby. Security calls the police. The police tell them to leave. Both VPs storm off, separately, muttering threats at each other.

Continue to 1.4 →