← 4.3
Act 4, Scene 4 — London. Before the Palace
on stage:
Next: 4.5 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument A gathering of powerful nobles discussing Richmond's claim to the throne.
Enter old Queen Margaret.
QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [witnessing the kingdom rot from hiding — dark satisfaction, vindication, yet hunger for more bloodshed]

So now prosperity begins to mellow,

And drop into the rotten mouth of death.

Here in these confines slily have I lurked

To watch the waning of mine enemies.

A dire induction am I witness to,

And will to France, hoping the consequence

Will prove as bitter, black, and tragical.

Withdraw thee, wretched Margaret. Who comes here?

[_Retires._]
Enter Duchess of York and Queen Elizabeth.
QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [absolute raw grief, desperate bargaining with God, calling out to her dead children's spirits — she's in pieces]

Ah, my poor Princes! Ah, my tender babes,

My unblown flowers, new-appearing sweets!

If yet your gentle souls fly in the air

And be not fixed in doom perpetual,

Hover about me with your airy wings

And hear your mother’s lamentation.

[_Aside_.] Hover about her; say that right for right
QUEEN MARGARET [sharp mockery, bitter confirmation of what she's saying]

Hath dimmed your infant morn to aged night.

DUCHESS ≋ verse [voice completely broken from years of sorrow, can barely speak, losing her own children]

So many miseries have crazed my voice

That my woe-wearied tongue is still and mute.

Edward Plantagenet, why art thou dead?

[_Aside_.] Plantagenet doth quit Plantagenet;
QUEEN MARGARET [grim tit-for-tat justice, one Edward killed another — dark satisfaction at the symmetry]

Edward for Edward pays a dying debt.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [accusing God Himself, unable to comprehend how He could let this happen, absolute despair]

Wilt thou, O God, fly from such gentle lambs,

And throw them in the entrails of the wolf?

When didst Thou sleep when such a deed was done?

[_Aside_.] When holy Harry died, and my sweet son.
DUCHESS ≋ verse [poetic lament, almost delusional with grief, Richard is a contradiction made flesh]

Dead life, blind sight, poor mortal living ghost,

Woe’s scene, world’s shame, grave’s due by life usurped,

Brief abstract and record of tedious days,

Rest thy unrest on England’s lawful earth,

[_Sitting_.] Unlawfully made drunk with innocent blood.
QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [bitter desperation, if even the grave could grant her escape, she'd beg for it]

Ah, that thou wouldst as soon afford a grave

As thou canst yield a melancholy seat,

Then would I hide my bones, not rest them here.

[_Sitting_.] Ah, who hath any cause to mourn but we?
[_Coming forward._]
QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [demanding, forcing herself to the front—her grief is older and deeper than anyone's]

If ancient sorrow be most reverend,

Give mine the benefit of seigniory,

And let my griefs frown on the upper hand.

If sorrow can admit society,

[_Sitting down with them._]
Tell o’er your woes again by viewing mine.
I had an Edward, till a Richard killed him;
I had a husband, till a Richard killed him.
Thou hadst an Edward, till a Richard killed him;
Thou hadst a Richard, till a Richard killed him.
DUCHESS ≋ verse [accusing Margaret directly—you killed my son Rutland and my other son]

I had a Richard too, and thou didst kill him;

I had a Rutland too; thou holp’st to kill him.

QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [ferocious, detailing Richard as an unholy monster—this is her master curse]

Thou hadst a Clarence too, and Richard killed him.

From forth the kennel of thy womb hath crept

A hell-hound that doth hunt us all to death:

That dog, that had his teeth before his eyes,

To worry lambs and lap their gentle blood;

That excellent grand tyrant of the earth,

That reigns in galled eyes of weeping souls;

That foul defacer of God’s handiwork

Thy womb let loose to chase us to our graves.

O upright, just, and true-disposing God,

How do I thank thee that this carnal cur

Preys on the issue of his mother’s body,

And makes her pew-fellow with others’ moan!

DUCHESS ≋ verse [defensive, grieving both of their losses but standing firm against Margaret's grief]

O Harry’s wife, triumph not in my woes!

God witness with me, I have wept for thine.

QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [gorged on revenge, satisfied with her curses, watching justice unfold—this is her climax]

Bear with me. I am hungry for revenge,

And now I cloy me with beholding it.

Thy Edward he is dead, that killed my Edward;

The other Edward dead, to quit my Edward;

Young York, he is but boot, because both they

Matched not the high perfection of my loss.

Thy Clarence he is dead that stabbed my Edward;

And the beholders of this frantic play,

Th’ adulterate Hastings, Rivers, Vaughan, Grey,

Untimely smothered in their dusky graves.

Richard yet lives, hell’s black intelligencer,

Only reserved their factor to buy souls

And send them thither. But at hand, at hand

Ensues his piteous and unpitied end.

Earth gapes, hell burns, fiends roar, saints pray,

To have him suddenly conveyed from hence.

Cancel his bond of life, dear God, I pray,

That I may live to say “The dog is dead.”

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [horrified recognition—Margaret was right, and Elizabeth now understands Richard is inhuman]

O, thou didst prophesy the time would come

That I should wish for thee to help me curse

That bottled spider, that foul bunch-backed toad!

QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [devastatingly specific—laying out everything Elizabeth lost, from power to family to hope]

I called thee then, vain flourish of my fortune;

I called thee then, poor shadow, painted queen,

The presentation of but what I was,

The flattering index of a direful pageant;

One heaved a-high to be hurled down below,

A mother only mocked with two fair babes;

A dream of what thou wast; a garish flag,

To be the aim of every dangerous shot;

A sign of dignity, a breath, a bubble;

A queen in jest, only to fill the scene.

Where is thy husband now? Where be thy brothers?

Where are thy two sons? Wherein dost thou joy?

Who sues, and kneels, and says, “God save the Queen?”

Where be the bending peers that flattered thee?

Where be the thronging troops that followed thee?

Decline all this, and see what now thou art:

For happy wife, a most distressed widow;

For joyful mother, one that wails the name;

For one being sued to, one that humbly sues;

For Queen, a very caitiff crowned with care;

For she that scorned at me, now scorned of me;

For she being feared of all, now fearing one;

For she commanding all, obeyed of none.

Thus hath the course of justice wheeled about

And left thee but a very prey to time,

Having no more but thought of what thou wast

To torture thee the more, being what thou art.

Thou didst usurp my place, and dost thou not

Usurp the just proportion of my sorrow?

Now thy proud neck bears half my burdened yoke,

From which even here I slip my weary head,

And leave the burden of it all on thee.

Farewell, York’s wife, and Queen of sad mischance.

These English woes shall make me smile in France.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [desperate to learn, wanting to match Margaret's power to curse—she's finally understanding]

O thou well skilled in curses, stay awhile,

And teach me how to curse mine enemies.

QUEEN MARGARET ≋ verse [offering her hard-won wisdom, the instruction for eternal torment]

Forbear to sleep the night, and fast the days;

Compare dead happiness with living woe;

Think that thy babes were sweeter than they were,

And he that slew them fouler than he is.

Bettering thy loss makes the bad-causer worse.

Revolving this will teach thee how to curse.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [humble, knowing her words are weak compared to what she needs to say]

My words are dull. O, quicken them with thine!

QUEEN MARGARET [passing the torch, knowing Elizabeth's pain will fuel her curse better than any lesson]

Thy woes will make them sharp and pierce like mine.

[_Exit._]
DUCHESS [exhausted, beyond words, asking why speech is even necessary when sorrow is total]

Why should calamity be full of words?

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [defending speech itself as cathartic even if useless—words are the only medicine for grief]

Windy attorneys to their clients’ woes,

Airy succeeders of intestate joys,

Poor breathing orators of miseries,

Let them have scope, though what they do impart

Help nothing else, yet do they ease the heart.

DUCHESS ≋ verse [eager to curse Richard with Elizabeth, invoking the smothering of her grandsons against Richard]

If so, then be not tongue-tied. Go with me,

And in the breath of bitter words let’s smother

My damned son, that thy two sweet sons smothered.

[_A trumpet sounds._]
The trumpet sounds. Be copious in exclaims.
Enter King Richard and his Train, including Catesby, marching.
KING RICHARD [authoritative, commanding, expecting instant obedience—bemused and slightly annoyed to be stopped]

Who intercepts me in my expedition?

DUCHESS ≋ verse [bitter fantasy—she should have strangled him in the womb, prevented all the horror]

O, she that might have intercepted thee,

By strangling thee in her accursed womb,

From all the slaughters, wretch, that thou hast done.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [accusatory, demanding—that crown belongs on a dead man's head, and her sons should wear it]

Hid’st thou that forehead with a golden crown

Where should be branded, if that right were right,

The slaughter of the Prince that owed that crown,

And the dire death of my poor sons and brothers?

Tell me, thou villain-slave, where are my children?

DUCHESS ≋ verse [demanding, her voice sharp—naming the dead to make Richard confront his murders]

Thou toad, thou toad, where is thy brother Clarence,

And little Ned Plantagenet his son?

QUEEN ELIZABETH [continuing the roll call of the dead, her voice joined with the Duchess's]

Where is the gentle Rivers, Vaughan, Grey?

DUCHESS [adding another name to the litany, the weight accumulating]

Where is kind Hastings?

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [not engaging with the accusations, using power and noise to drown them out—performative kingship]

A flourish, trumpets! Strike alarum, drums!

Let not the heavens hear these tell-tale women

Rail on the Lord’s anointed. Strike, I say!

[_Flourish. Alarums._]
Either be patient and entreat me fair,
Or with the clamorous report of war
Thus will I drown your exclamations.
DUCHESS [cutting, disowning—you're no son of mine]

Art thou my son?

KING RICHARD [formal, cold, polite in the way that masks contempt—giving the answer she expects]

Ay, I thank God, my father, and yourself.

DUCHESS [setting a condition—she'll try to speak calmly if he'll listen]

Then patiently hear my impatience.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [matching her, but turning it against her—I inherited your temper, so I can't bear criticism either]

Madam, I have a touch of your condition,

That cannot brook the accent of reproof.

DUCHESS [pleading now, will he just let her speak]

O, let me speak!

KING RICHARD [shutting her down, but offering the performance of listening without actually listening]

Do then, but I’ll not hear.

DUCHESS [trying to meet him halfway, calming herself down]

I will be mild and gentle in my words.

KING RICHARD [eager to leave, impatient, using time pressure as an excuse to avoid the conversation]

And brief, good mother, for I am in haste.

DUCHESS ≋ verse [bitter accusation—she's waited all his life, and he's always too busy for her]

Art thou so hasty? I have stayed for thee,

God knows, in torment and in agony.

KING RICHARD [deflecting, offering token comfort—wasn't I there in the end?]

And came I not at last to comfort you?

DUCHESS ≋ verse [comprehensive damnation—your entire life has been a nightmare, and you've never given me one good moment]

No, by the Holy Rood, thou know’st it well

Thou cam’st on earth to make the earth my hell.

A grievous burden was thy birth to me;

Tetchy and wayward was thy infancy;

Thy school-days frightful, desp’rate, wild, and furious;

Thy prime of manhood daring, bold, and venturous;

Thy age confirmed, proud, subtle, sly, and bloody,

More mild, but yet more harmful, kind in hatred.

What comfortable hour canst thou name

That ever graced me with thy company?

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [dismissive, offering to leave—the only pleasant person he knew was one minor figure]

Faith, none but Humphrey Hower, that called your Grace

To breakfast once, forth of my company.

If I be so disgracious in your eye,

Let me march on and not offend you, madam.

Strike up the drum.

DUCHESS [desperate, trying one last time to make him listen before he goes]

I prithee, hear me speak.

KING RICHARD [dismissing her, saying her words are toxic and hateful]

You speak too bitterly.

DUCHESS ≋ verse [final chance—this is her last word to him ever, make him listen]

Hear me a word,

For I shall never speak to thee again.

KING RICHARD [cold assent—saying nothing, just letting her continue, unmoved]

So.

DUCHESS ≋ verse [bringing down divine judgment—not her curse but God's, and the souls of her grandsons working against him]

Either thou wilt die by God’s just ordinance

Ere from this war thou turn a conqueror,

Or I with grief and extreme age shall perish

And never more behold thy face again.

Therefore take with thee my most grievous curse,

Which in the day of battle tire thee more

Than all the complete armour that thou wear’st.

My prayers on the adverse party fight;

And there the little souls of Edward’s children

Whisper the spirits of thine enemies

And promise them success and victory.

Bloody thou art; bloody will be thy end.

Shame serves thy life and doth thy death attend.

[_Exit._]
QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [less eloquent than Margaret but joining the curse, amen—so be it]

Though far more cause, yet much less spirit to curse

Abides in me, I say amen to her.

KING RICHARD [courteous, but commanding—he wants her attention and he's used to getting it]

Stay, madam, I must talk a word with you.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [defensive, protecting her daughters—they're all I have left, and you can't have them]

I have no more sons of the royal blood

For thee to slaughter. For my daughters, Richard,

They shall be praying nuns, not weeping queens,

And therefore level not to hit their lives.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [changing tactics—appealing to her pride in her daughter Elizabeth's virtue and beauty]

You have a daughter called Elizabeth,

Virtuous and fair, royal and gracious.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [desperate bargaining—she'll destroy her daughter's reputation to save her life]

And must she die for this? O, let her live,

And I’ll corrupt her manners, stain her beauty,

Slander myself as false to Edward’s bed,

Throw over her the veil of infamy.

So she may live unscarred of bleeding slaughter,

I will confess she was not Edward’s daughter.

KING RICHARD [reassuring her but with a hidden purpose—claiming virtue when he has none]

Wrong not her birth; she is a royal princess.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [willing to do anything to protect her—the birth legitimacy means nothing if he kills her]

To save her life I’ll say she is not so.

KING RICHARD [stating what sounds like protection but is actually threat—her royal birth is exactly why she'll be safe]

Her life is safest only in her birth.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the horrible irony—her brothers' royal blood was supposed to protect them, and that's why Richard killed them]

And only in that safety died her brothers.

KING RICHARD [deflecting to fate—the stars were against them, not his actions]

Lo, at their births good stars were opposite.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [her challenge—no, it wasn't fate, it was you being evil to people who trusted you]

No, to their lives ill friends were contrary.

KING RICHARD [calm, fatalistic—destiny can't be avoided, so he can't be blamed]

All unavoided is the doom of destiny.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [her counter—grace (goodness) can change destiny, and if you'd been good, they'd be alive]

True, when avoided grace makes destiny.

My babes were destined to a fairer death,

If grace had blessed thee with a fairer life.

KING RICHARD [defensive, denying the murders—they were accidents of fate, not his will]

You speak as if that I had slain my cousins.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [searing indictment—you didn't personally kill them, but your will is the knife that did]

Cousins, indeed, and by their uncle cozened

Of comfort, kingdom, kindred, freedom, life.

Whose hand soever lanced their tender hearts,

Thy head, all indirectly, gave direction.

No doubt the murd’rous knife was dull and blunt

Till it was whetted on thy stone-hard heart,

To revel in the entrails of my lambs.

But that still use of grief makes wild grief tame,

My tongue should to thy ears not name my boys

Till that my nails were anchored in thine eyes,

And I, in such a desp’rate bay of death,

Like a poor bark of sails and tackling reft,

Rush all to pieces on thy rocky bosom.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [appealing to her through oath—as I succeed in war, I promise you good, not harm]

Madam, so thrive I in my enterprise

And dangerous success of bloody wars,

As I intend more good to you and yours

Than ever you or yours by me were harmed!

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [suspicious—what good can come from you? Hidden good? What does that even mean?]

What good is covered with the face of heaven,

To be discovered, that can do me good?

KING RICHARD [smooth pivot—advancing her remaining children, providing for them]

Th’ advancement of your children, gentle lady.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [bitter sarcasm—advancement to the scaffold, to the executioner's block]

Up to some scaffold, there to lose their heads.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [grandiose—I'm offering the highest honors, imperial status]

Unto the dignity and height of fortune,

The high imperial type of this earth’s glory.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [challenging—prove it, what exactly can you offer? Titles mean nothing]

Flatter my sorrows with report of it.

Tell me what state, what dignity, what honour,

Canst thou demise to any child of mine?

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [sweeping offer—everything I have, including myself, if it washes away your anger]

Even all I have—ay, and myself and all

Will I withal endow a child of thine;

So in the Lethe of thy angry soul

Thou drown the sad remembrance of those wrongs

Which thou supposest I have done to thee.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [impatient—your kindness speech will outlast your kindness itself, so stop talking]

Be brief, lest that the process of thy kindness

Last longer telling than thy kindness’ date.

KING RICHARD [direct assertion—I love your daughter from my very soul]

Then know, that from my soul I love thy daughter.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [sarcastic—sure, if you love her the way you loved her brothers]

My daughter’s mother thinks it with her soul.

KING RICHARD [pushing for clarity—what are you saying?]

What do you think?

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [mock-innocence—I'm just saying you love her with your soul the way you loved them, and for that I thank you]

That thou dost love my daughter from thy soul.

So from thy soul’s love didst thou love her brothers,

And from my heart’s love I do thank thee for it.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [clarifying—don't confuse what I mean, I love her and want to make her Queen]

Be not so hasty to confound my meaning.

I mean that with my soul I love thy daughter,

And do intend to make her Queen of England.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [catching the implication—if she's queen, who's the king? (Richard)]

Well, then, who dost thou mean shall be her king?

KING RICHARD [matter-of-fact—the man who makes her queen, obviously]

Even he that makes her Queen. Who else should be?

QUEEN ELIZABETH [shocked, but playing innocent—you?]

What, thou?

KING RICHARD [straightforward, asking her what she thinks of this plan]

Even so. How think you of it?

QUEEN ELIZABETH [playing along—how exactly would you court her? How would you win her over?]

How canst thou woo her?

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [appealing to her as expert—you know her best, teach me how to approach her]

That would I learn of you,

As one being best acquainted with her humour.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [setting the trap—will you really listen to my advice?]

And wilt thou learn of me?

KING RICHARD [eager, wanting her cooperation—with all his heart]

Madam, with all my heart.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [laying out the impossible task—send her the hearts of her brothers, remind her of every murder]

Send to her, by the man that slew her brothers,

A pair of bleeding hearts; thereon engrave

“Edward” and “York.” Then haply will she weep.

Therefore present to her—as sometimes Margaret

Did to thy father, steeped in Rutland’s blood—

A handkerchief, which, say to her, did drain

The purple sap from her sweet brothers’ body,

And bid her wipe her weeping eyes withal.

If this inducement move her not to love,

Send her a letter of thy noble deeds;

Tell her thou mad’st away her uncle Clarence,

Her uncle Rivers, ay, and for her sake

Mad’st quick conveyance with her good aunt Anne.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [recognizing the mockery—you're mocking me, this isn't real advice]

You mock me, madam; this is not the way

To win your daughter.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [the truth beneath the sarcasm—there is no other way, unless you weren't Richard]

There is no other way,

Unless thou couldst put on some other shape,

And not be Richard, that hath done all this.

KING RICHARD [last appeal—what if I say I did it all for love of her?]

Say that I did all this for love of her?

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [then she hates you even more—love paid for with blood is not love]

Nay, then indeed she cannot choose but hate thee,

Having bought love with such a bloody spoil.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [transformation pitch—what's done is done, but I'll make amends by raising her status through marriage and giving her a dynasty]

Look what is done cannot be now amended.

Men shall deal unadvisedly sometimes,

Which after-hours gives leisure to repent.

If I did take the kingdom from your sons,

To make amends I’ll give it to your daughter.

If I have killed the issue of your womb,

To quicken your increase I will beget

Mine issue of your blood upon your daughter.

A grandam’s name is little less in love

Than is the doting title of a mother;

They are as children but one step below,

Even of your mettle, of your very blood;

Of all one pain, save for a night of groans

Endured of her, for whom you bid like sorrow.

Your children were vexation to your youth,

But mine shall be a comfort to your age.

The loss you have is but a son being King,

And by that loss your daughter is made Queen.

I cannot make you what amends I would;

Therefore accept such kindness as I can.

Dorset your son, that with a fearful soul

Leads discontented steps in foreign soil,

This fair alliance quickly shall call home

To high promotions and great dignity.

The King, that calls your beauteous daughter wife,

Familiarly shall call thy Dorset brother;

Again shall you be mother to a king,

And all the ruins of distressful times

Repaired with double riches of content.

What, we have many goodly days to see.

The liquid drops of tears that you have shed

Shall come again, transformed to orient pearl,

Advantaging their loan with interest

Of ten times double gain of happiness.

Go then, my mother, to thy daughter go.

Make bold her bashful years with your experience;

Prepare her ears to hear a wooer’s tale;

Put in her tender heart th’ aspiring flame

Of golden sovereignty; acquaint the Princess

With the sweet silent hours of marriage joys,

And when this arm of mine hath chastised

The petty rebel, dull-brained Buckingham,

Bound with triumphant garlands will I come

And lead thy daughter to a conqueror’s bed;

To whom I will retail my conquest won,

And she shall be sole victoress, Caesar’s Caesar.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [asking the impossible—how do I even introduce you? Your identity is the problem]

What were I best to say? Her father’s brother

Would be her lord? Or shall I say her uncle?

Or he that slew her brothers and her uncles?

Under what title shall I woo for thee,

That God, the law, my honour, and her love

Can make seem pleasing to her tender years?

KING RICHARD [simplifying—just say this marriage brings peace to England]

Infer fair England’s peace by this alliance.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the dark irony—she'll buy peace by constantly fighting wars]

Which she shall purchase with still-lasting war.

KING RICHARD [commanding—the King doesn't beg, he entreats (politely commands)]

Tell her the King, that may command, entreats.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [God forbids it—what God forbids, even a king can't command]

That at her hands, which the King’s King forbids.

KING RICHARD [offering high status—she'll be a great queen]

Say she shall be a high and mighty queen.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [sarcasm—to bow down in defeat, like her mother will have to]

To vail the title, as her mother doth.

KING RICHARD [swearing eternal love—I will love her forever]

Say I will love her everlastingly.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [challenging the word forever—how long is forever?]

But how long shall that title “ever” last?

KING RICHARD [assuring—as long as she lives, sweet and strong]

Sweetly in force unto her fair life’s end.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the final knife—how long will her life last with you?]

But how long fairly shall her sweet life last?

KING RICHARD [evasive answer—as long as heaven allows, deferring to fate]

As long as heaven and nature lengthens it.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [dark certainty—as long as hell is comfortable with Richard's presence]

As long as hell and Richard likes of it.

KING RICHARD [romantic reversal—I'll be beneath her, a slave to her]

Say I, her sovereign, am her subject low.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [she loathes him even in submission]

But she, your subject, loathes such sovereignty.

KING RICHARD [asking her to advocate for him—be eloquent for me]

Be eloquent in my behalf to her.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the best way to tell truth is plainly, without ornamentation]

An honest tale speeds best being plainly told.

KING RICHARD [taking the hint—then tell her plainly that I love her]

Then plainly to her tell my loving tale.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [paradox—plain and honest are opposites when it comes to Richard]

Plain and not honest is too harsh a style.

KING RICHARD [impatient—she's making quick surface objections, not thinking deeply]

Your reasons are too shallow and too quick.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [her reasons are deep—they're buried with her dead children]

O no, my reasons are too deep and dead—

Too deep and dead, poor infants, in their graves.

KING RICHARD [telling her to stop—don't keep talking about it, it's in the past]

Harp not on that string, madam; that is past.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [she will never stop—she'll harp on it until her heart breaks]

Harp on it still shall I till heart-strings break.

KING RICHARD [swearing by his sacred regalia—George (the saint), his Garter (order of chivalry), his crown]

Now, by my George, my Garter, and my crown—

QUEEN ELIZABETH [all three are corrupt—desecrated, disgraced, and stolen]

Profaned, dishonoured, and the third usurped.

KING RICHARD [continuing his oath—I swear—]

I swear—

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [systematically demolishing each symbol he tries to swear by—they're all corrupted by his actions]

By nothing, for this is no oath.

Thy George, profaned, hath lost his lordly honour;

Thy Garter, blemished, pawned his knightly virtue;

Thy crown, usurped, disgraced his kingly glory.

If something thou wouldst swear to be believed,

Swear then by something that thou hast not wronged.

KING RICHARD [trying another oath—now by the world]

Now, by the world—

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the world is full of his crimes]

’Tis full of thy foul wrongs.

KING RICHARD [trying by his father's memory—my father's death—]

My father’s death—

QUEEN ELIZABETH [even his father's death is disgraced by Richard's life]

Thy life hath that dishonoured.

KING RICHARD [finally—swearing by himself, running out of options]

Then, by myself—

QUEEN ELIZABETH [you yourself are corrupted by your own crimes]

Thyself is self-misused.

KING RICHARD [grasping—by God then—]

Why, then, by God—

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [God is most wronged by Richard—if he feared God's oath, none of this would have happened]

God’s wrong is most of all.

If thou didst fear to break an oath with Him,

The unity the King my husband made

Thou hadst not broken, nor my brothers died.

If thou hadst feared to break an oath by Him,

Th’ imperial metal circling now thy head

Had graced the tender temples of my child,

And both the Princes had been breathing here,

Which now, two tender bedfellows for dust,

Thy broken faith hath made a prey for worms.

What canst thou swear by now?

KING RICHARD [the future—a new beginning]

The time to come.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [the future is corrupted by the past—the damage is already done]

That thou hast wronged in the time o’erpast;

For I myself have many tears to wash

Hereafter time, for time past wronged by thee.

The children live whose fathers thou hast slaughtered,

Ungoverned youth, to wail it in their age;

The parents live whose children thou hast butchered,

Old barren plants, to wail it with their age.

Swear not by time to come, for that thou hast

Misused ere used, by times ill-used o’erpast.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [invoking heaven and fortune against himself if he lies—a final, desperate appeal]

As I intend to prosper and repent,

So thrive I in my dangerous affairs

Of hostile arms! Myself myself confound!

Heaven and fortune bar me happy hours!

Day, yield me not thy light, nor, night, thy rest!

Be opposite all planets of good luck

To my proceeding if with dear heart’s love,

Immaculate devotion, holy thoughts,

I tender not thy beauteous princely daughter.

In her consists my happiness and thine;

Without her follows to myself and thee,

Herself, the land, and many a Christian soul,

Death, desolation, ruin, and decay.

It cannot be avoided but by this;

It will not be avoided but by this.

Therefore, dear mother—I must call you so—

Be the attorney of my love to her;

Plead what I will be, not what I have been;

Not my deserts, but what I will deserve.

Urge the necessity and state of times,

And be not peevish found in great designs.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [horrified—tempted by the devil to do this awful thing]

Shall I be tempted of the devil thus?

KING RICHARD [reframing—yes, if the devil tempts you to do good]

Ay, if the devil tempt you to do good.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [but this would mean forgetting who I am]

Shall I forget myself to be myself?

KING RICHARD [paradox—yes, if remembering yourself hurts you]

Ay, if your self’s remembrance wrong yourself.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the core fact—you murdered them]

Yet thou didst kill my children.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [redemption through her womb—their memory will live in new children]

But in your daughter’s womb I bury them,

Where, in that nest of spicery, they will breed

Selves of themselves, to your recomforture.

QUEEN ELIZABETH [the moment of decision—will I do this?]

Shall I go win my daughter to thy will?

KING RICHARD [and you'll be happy again—a mother to a queen]

And be a happy mother by the deed.

QUEEN ELIZABETH ≋ verse [agreement—I'll go, and I'll send word of her response]

I go. Write to me very shortly,

And you shall understand from me her mind.

KING RICHARD [farewell—give her my love, the promise of devotion]

Bear her my true love’s kiss; and so, farewell.

[_Kissing her. Exit Queen Elizabeth._]
Relenting fool, and shallow, changing woman!
Enter Ratcliffe.
How now, what news?
RATCLIFFE ≋ verse [military crisis—a navy has arrived, possibly Richmond and rebels]

Most mighty sovereign, on the western coast

Rideth a puissant navy; to our shores

Throng many doubtful hollow-hearted friends,

Unarmed, and unresolved to beat them back.

’Tis thought that Richmond is their admiral;

And there they hull, expecting but the aid

Of Buckingham to welcome them ashore.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [immediate response—send word to Norfolk to prepare]

Some light-foot friend post to the Duke of Norfolk.

Ratcliffe, thyself, or Catesby. Where is he?

CATESBY [ready to serve—immediate response]

Here, my good lord.

KING RICHARD [commanding—go quickly to Norfolk]

Catesby, fly to the Duke.

CATESBY [immediate compliance—I'll go as fast as possible]

I will my lord, with all convenient haste.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [redirecting orders to Ratcliffe—go to Salisbury]

Ratcliffe, come hither. Post to Salisbury.

When thou com’st thither—

[_To Catesby._] Dull, unmindful villain,
Why stay’st thou here, and go’st not to the Duke?
CATESBY ≋ verse [asking for clarification before going—what's the message?]

First, mighty liege, tell me your Highness’ pleasure,

What from your Grace I shall deliver to him.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [ordering immediate military mobilization—raise every soldier]

O, true, good Catesby. Bid him levy straight

The greatest strength and power that he can make,

And meet me suddenly at Salisbury.

CATESBY [going—immediate obedience]

I go.

[_Exit._]
RATCLIFFE [asking what to do—clarifying the mission]

What, may it please you, shall I do at Salisbury?

KING RICHARD [challenging—why are you asking now? You already know the plan]

Why, what wouldst thou do there before I go?

RATCLIFFE [reminding—you told me to post ahead earlier]

Your Highness told me I should post before.

KING RICHARD [changing his mind—plans have shifted]

My mind is changed.

Enter Stanley Earl of Derby.
Stanley, what news with you?
STANLEY ≋ verse [diplomatically evasive—nothing good or bad to report, just saying it's fine either way]

None good, my liege, to please you with the hearing;

Nor none so bad but well may be reported.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [impatient—stop dodging, what's the actual news?]

Hoyday, a riddle! Neither good nor bad.

What need’st thou run so many miles about

When thou mayst tell thy tale the nearest way?

Once more, what news?

STANLEY [simple fact—Richmond is at sea heading here]

Richmond is on the seas.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [furious—wishing him dead, calling him a coward]

There let him sink, and be the seas on him!

White-livered runagate, what doth he there?

STANLEY [uncertain—I'm guessing, not sure]

I know not, mighty sovereign, but by guess.

KING RICHARD [pushing—well then, what's your guess?]

Well, as you guess?

STANLEY ≋ verse [naming conspirators—egged on by traitors to claim the crown]

Stirred up by Dorset, Buckingham, and Morton,

He makes for England, here to claim the crown.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [rhetorical fury—I'm the lawful king, what right has he?]

Is the chair empty? Is the sword unswayed?

Is the King dead? The empire unpossessed?

What heir of York is there alive but we?

And who is England’s King but great York’s heir?

Then tell me, what makes he upon the seas?

STANLEY [evasive—I can't guess any other reason]

Unless for that, my liege, I cannot guess.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [accusatory threat—unless he's coming to be king, unless you're about to betray me]

Unless for that he comes to be your liege,

You cannot guess wherefore the Welshman comes.

Thou wilt revolt and fly to him, I fear.

STANLEY [denying—assuring his loyalty]

No, my good lord; therefore mistrust me not.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [accusing—where's your army? Are they helping the rebels?]

Where is thy power, then, to beat him back?

Where be thy tenants and thy followers?

Are they not now upon the western shore,

Safe-conducting the rebels from their ships?

STANLEY [deflecting—my friends are in the north]

No, my good lord, my friends are in the north.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [sarcastic—good friends who aren't here when needed]

Cold friends to me. What do they in the north,

When they should serve their sovereign in the west?

STANLEY ≋ verse [offering—give me permission and I'll gather them]

They have not been commanded, mighty King.

Pleaseth your Majesty to give me leave,

I’ll muster up my friends, and meet your Grace

Where and what time your Majesty shall please.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [suspicious—you'll go join Richmond, won't you?]

Ay, ay, thou wouldst be gone to join with Richmond.

But I’ll not trust thee.

STANLEY ≋ verse [protesting loyalty—you have no reason to doubt me]

Most mighty sovereign,

You have no cause to hold my friendship doubtful.

I never was nor never will be false.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [conditional trust with a threat—go, but leave your son as a hostage]

Go then, and muster men, but leave behind

Your son George Stanley. Look your heart be firm,

Or else his head’s assurance is but frail.

STANLEY [accepting the terms—treat him as I prove true]

So deal with him as I prove true to you.

[_Exit._]
Enter a Messenger.
MESSENGER ≋ verse [reporting rebellion spreading—more forces joining the enemy]

My gracious sovereign, now in Devonshire,

As I by friends am well advertised,

Sir Edward Courtney, and the haughty prelate,

Bishop of Exeter, his elder brother,

With many more confederates, are in arms.

Enter another Messenger.
SECOND MESSENGER ≋ verse [more bad news—Kent is rising, more rebels joining]

In Kent, my liege, the Guilfords are in arms,

And every hour more competitors

Flock to the rebels, and their power grows strong.

Enter another Messenger.
THIRD MESSENGER [beginning report—about Buckingham's army]

My lord, the army of great Buckingham—

KING RICHARD [furious at the barrage of bad news—all these messengers bring nothing but death]

Out on you, owls! Nothing but songs of death?

[_He strikes him._]
There, take thou that till thou bring better news.
THIRD MESSENGER ≋ verse [actually good news—Buckingham's army scattered, he's lost]

The news I have to tell your Majesty

Is, that by sudden floods and fall of waters,

Buckingham’s army is dispersed and scattered,

And he himself wandered away alone,

No man knows whither.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [relieved, apologetic—that's actually good, here's a reward]

I cry thee mercy.

There is my purse to cure that blow of thine.

Hath any well-advised friend proclaimed

Reward to him that brings the traitor in?

THIRD MESSENGER [yes—proclamations have been issued]

Such proclamation hath been made, my lord.

Enter another Messenger.
FOURTH MESSENGER ≋ verse [mixed news—Yorkshire rebels but Richmond's had to flee back to Brittany]

Sir Thomas Lovell and Lord Marquess Dorset,

’Tis said, my liege, in Yorkshire are in arms.

But this good comfort bring I to your Highness:

The Breton navy is dispersed by tempest.

Richmond, in Dorsetshire, sent out a boat

Unto the shore, to ask those on the banks

If they were his assistants, yea or no?—

Who answered him they came from Buckingham

Upon his party. He, mistrusting them,

Hoised sail, and made his course again for Brittany.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [rallying—we're armed now, let's fight, whether foreign enemies or rebels]

March on, march on, since we are up in arms,

If not to fight with foreign enemies,

Yet to beat down these rebels here at home.

Enter Catesby.
CATESBY ≋ verse [mixed news—Buckingham captured (good) but Richmond landed with an army (bad)]

My liege, the Duke of Buckingham is taken.

That is the best news. That the Earl of Richmond

Is with a mighty power landed at Milford

Is colder tidings, yet they must be told.

KING RICHARD ≋ verse [urgent—no time for talk, march to Salisbury and fight]

Away towards Salisbury! While we reason here

A royal battle might be won and lost.

Someone take order Buckingham be brought

To Salisbury; the rest march on with me.

[_Flourish. Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

Elizabeth confronts Richard about his crimes and the fate of her children.

If this happened today…

When ambition destroys trust, even victory becomes a hollow shell of fear.

Continue to 4.5 →