← 4.3
Act 4, Scene 4 — Wales. Before the cave of Belarius.
on stage:
Next: 5.1 →
Original
Faithful Conversational Text-message
The argument Belarius urges retreat into the mountains to avoid the Roman-British war, but Guiderius and Arviragus refuse and insist on fighting; Belarius, moved by their princely courage, agrees to join them.
Enter Belarius, Guiderius and Arviragus.
GUIDERIUS dialogue

The noise is round about us.

The noise is round about us.

the noise is round about us.

the noise is round about us....

BELARIUS dialogue

Let us from it.

Let us from it.

let us from it.

let us from it....

ARVIRAGUS ≋ verse dialogue

What pleasure, sir, find we in life, to lock it

From action and adventure?

What pleasure, sir, find we in life, to lock it From action and adventure?

what pleasure, sir, find we in life, to lock it from action and adventure?

what pleasure, sir, find we in life, to lock it fr...

GUIDERIUS ≋ verse dialogue

Nay, what hope

Have we in hiding us? This way the Romans

Must or for Britons slay us, or receive us

For barbarous and unnatural revolts

During their use, and slay us after.

Nay, what hope Have we in hiding us? This way the Romans Must or for Britons slay us, or receive us For barbarous and unnatural revolts During their use, and slay us after.

nay, what hope have we in hiding us? this way the romans must or for britons slay us, or receive us for barbarous and unnatural revolts during their use, and slay us after.

nay, what hope have we in hiding us? this way the ...

BELARIUS ≋ verse danger

Sons,

We’ll higher to the mountains; there secure us.

To the King’s party there’s no going. Newness

Of Cloten’s death (we being not known, not muster’d

Among the bands) may drive us to a render

Where we have liv’d, and so extort from’s that

Which we have done, whose answer would be death,

Drawn on with torture.

Sons, We’ll higher to the mountains; there secure us. To the King’s party there’s no going. Newness Of Cloten’s death (we being not known, not muster’d Among the bands) may drive us to a render Where we have liv’d, and so extort from’s that Which we have done, whose answer would be death, Drawn on w

sons, we’ll higher to the mountains; there secure us. to the king’s party there’s no going. newness of cloten’s death (we being not known, not muster’d among the bands) may drive us to a render where we have liv’d, and so extort from’s that which we have done, whose answer would be death, drawn on w

sons, we’ll higher to the mountains; there secure

"Newness / Of Cloten's death" Guiderius killed Cloten in the previous act. Belarius correctly identifies this as a legal liability — they have no way to explain a royal's decapitation without implicating themselves.
GUIDERIUS ≋ verse dialogue

This is, sir, a doubt

In such a time nothing becoming you

Nor satisfying us.

This is, sir, a doubt In such a time nothing becoming you Nor satisfying us.

this is, sir, a doubt in such a time nothing becoming you nor satisfying us.

this is, sir, a doubt in such a time nothing becom...

ARVIRAGUS ≋ verse dialogue

It is not likely

That when they hear the Roman horses neigh,

Behold their quarter’d fires, have both their eyes

And ears so cloy’d importantly as now,

That they will waste their time upon our note,

To know from whence we are.

It is not likely That when they hear the Roman horses neigh, Behold their quarter’d fires, have both their eyes And ears so cloy’d importantly as now, That they will waste their time upon our note, To know from whence we are.

it is not likely that when they hear the roman horses neigh, behold their quarter’d fires, have both their eyes and ears so cloy’d importantly as now, that they will waste their time upon our note, to know from whence we are.

it is not likely that when they hear the roman hor

BELARIUS ≋ verse affection

O, I am known

Of many in the army. Many years,

Though Cloten then but young, you see, not wore him

From my remembrance. And, besides, the King

Hath not deserv’d my service nor your loves,

Who find in my exile the want of breeding,

The certainty of this hard life; aye hopeless

To have the courtesy your cradle promis’d,

But to be still hot summer’s tanlings and

The shrinking slaves of winter.

O, I am known Of many in the army. Many years, Though Cloten then but young, you see, not wore him From my remembrance. And, besides, the King has not deserv’d my service nor your loves, Who find in my exile the want of breeding, The certainty of this hard life; aye hopeless To have the courtesy you

o, i am known of many in the army. many years, though cloten then but young, you see, not wore him from my remembrance. and, besides, the king has not deserv’d my service nor your loves, who find in my exile the want of breeding, the certainty of this hard life; aye hopeless to have the courtesy you

o, i am known of many in the army. many years, tho

GUIDERIUS ≋ verse dialogue

Than be so,

Better to cease to be. Pray, sir, to th’ army.

I and my brother are not known; yourself

So out of thought, and thereto so o’ergrown,

Cannot be questioned.

Than be so, Better to cease to be. Pray, sir, to th’ army. I and my brother are not known; yourself So out of thought, and thereto so o’ergrown, Cannot be questioned.

than be so, better to cease to be. pray, sir, to th’ army. i and my brother are not known; yourself so out of thought, and thereto so o’ergrown, cannot be questioned.

than be so, better to cease to be. pray, sir, to t...

ARVIRAGUS ≋ verse dialogue

By this sun that shines,

I’ll thither. What thing is’t that I never

Did see man die! scarce ever look’d on blood

But that of coward hares, hot goats, and venison!

Never bestrid a horse, save one that had

A rider like myself, who ne’er wore rowel

Nor iron on his heel! I am asham’d

To look upon the holy sun, to have

The benefit of his blest beams, remaining

So long a poor unknown.

By this sun that shines, I’ll thither. What thing is’t that I never Did see man die! scarce ever look’d on blood But that of coward hares, hot goats, and venison! Never bestrid a horse, save one that had A rider like myself, who ne’er wore rowel Nor iron on his heel! I am asham’d To look upon the ho

by this sun that shines, i’ll thither. what thing is’t that i never did see man die! scarce ever look’d on blood but that of coward hares, hot goats, and venison! never bestrid a horse, save one that had a rider like myself, who ne’er wore rowel nor iron on his heel! i am asham’d to look upon the ho

by this sun that shines, i’ll thither. what thing

🎭 Dramatic irony Arviragus is ashamed that he has never seen a man die — but the audience knows he has just participated in Cloten's death in the previous act, even if indirectly. His shame is real, but the irony is that he's already closer to violence than he realizes.
GUIDERIUS ≋ verse dialogue

By heavens, I’ll go!

If you will bless me, sir, and give me leave,

I’ll take the better care; but if you will not,

The hazard therefore due fall on me by

The hands of Romans!

By heavens, I’ll go! If you will bless me, sir, and give me leave, I’ll take the better care; but if you will not, The hazard therefore due fall on me by The hands of Romans!

by heavens, i’ll go! if you will bless me, sir, and give me leave, i’ll take the better care; but if you will not, the hazard therefore due fall on me by the hands of romans!

by heavens, i’ll go! if you will bless me, sir, an...

ARVIRAGUS dialogue

So say I. Amen.

So say I. Amen.

so say i. amen.

so say i. amen.

BELARIUS dialogue

No reason I, since of your lives you set

So slight a valuation, should reserve

My crack’d one to more care. Have with you, boys!

If in your country wars you chance to die,

That is my bed too, lads, and there I’ll lie.

Lead, lead. [_Aside._] The time seems long; their blood thinks scorn

Till it fly out and show them princes born.

No reason I, since of your lives you set So slight a valuation, should reserve My crack’d one to more care. Have with you, boys! If in your country wars you chance to die, That is my bed too, lads, and there I’ll lie. Lead, lead. [_Aside._] The time seems long; their blood thinks scorn Till it fly o

no reason i, since of your lives you set so slight a valuation, should reserve my crack’d one to more care. have with you, boys! if in your country wars you chance to die, that is my bed too, lads, and there i’ll lie. lead, lead. [_aside._] the time seems long; their blood thinks scorn till it fly o

no reason i, since of your lives you set so slight

"their blood thinks scorn / Till it fly out and show them princes born" Belarius's aside is the play's argument about innate nobility made explicit: the princes' royal nature has always been in their blood, pressing to be expressed. Twenty years of cave life couldn't suppress what they were born as.
Why it matters This is the scene's turning point and its thesis. Belarius has spent twenty years hiding these boys from the world they were born into. Now he admits — to himself and to the audience — that nature always won.
[_Exeunt._]

The Reckoning

This is the scene where nature overrides nurture — or rather, proves they were the same thing all along. The brothers have been raised in a cave, cut off from the world of courts and battles, and yet the moment war arrives at their door, everything in them pulls toward it. Belarius's pragmatic caution looks like wisdom on paper; the boys' passionate refusal looks like recklessness. But the play is on the boys' side. When Belarius relents and mutters that their blood 'thinks scorn' until it can prove them princes, Shakespeare gives us the scene's real argument: some things cannot be hidden, even in a Welsh cave.

If this happened today…

Three people who've been living off-grid in the mountains for twenty years — two young men raised there and the older man who took them — hear that a war has started in the valley below. The older man says: stay hidden, we don't need the trouble, we'll go deeper into the hills. The younger two say: we're going. The older one argues: they'll arrest us. The younger two say: better to die trying than to rot up here doing nothing. The older man, who secretly knows the boys are princes, realizes he cannot keep suppressing who they are. He goes with them.

Continue to 5.1 →